
The United Nations is a strange institution. It is concurrently aspirational and a fraud (as it was designed to be by its five permanent members). Hypocrisy, as in so much of everything having to do with governance, is built into its diverse structures, none more so than its ill-named Security Council (if the “security” involved was meant to be global). The “security” it actually deals with involves maintaining a small number of states in control of the world; inept control unfortunately, and, of course, those states, five of them (plus Israel which controls one of them), are in turn controlled by a miniscule group of self-perpetuating oligarchs. Democracy, equality and sovereignty are its purported pillars but nothing could be further from the truth as both history and an examination of its governing charters makes clear. It does have one important function though (sort of), it is a place where representatives from almost all of the world’s “formal” governing institutions permanently gather. But, then again, it’s the “informal” who rule.
One of the United Nations deliberately incoherent institutions involves its chief administrative officer, the “secretary general”, the person who heads the United Nation’s secretariat. A figure who purportedly acts as the United Nations’ spokesman but more in the fashion that the current British monarch acts as the spokesperson for the government of the United Kingdom. That was not always the case. Initially, a number of United Nations secretaries general tried to buck the system apparently confused by the idealism reflected in the United Nations’ “Charter” but that was fairly quickly bred out of the office as exemplified by the tenure of Portugal’s António Guterres. Now, it’s once more time for the world to pick someone as the chief administrative officer at the United Nations, as its secretary general, and the process is at least interesting, as great powers vie with the other ten Security Council members to create the illusion that the person selected will play an important independent role[1].
As of November 2026, eight official candidates are actively vying to succeed António Guterres when his term ends on December 31, 2026, with Rebeca Grynspan of Costa Rica and Rafael Mariano Grossi of Argentina leading recent Security Council straw polls. Because the selection process uses informal regional rotation that favors the Latin American and Caribbean Group and faces growing calls to appoint the first female United Nations chief, five of the eight contenders are women and five hail from Latin America or the Caribbean. According to reporting on the Security Council’s eighth informal straw poll held in mid-November 2026, two candidates hold the strongest support: Rebeca Grynspan Mayufis (Costa Rica), the Jewish former vice president of Costa Rica and head of United Nations Trade and Development topped the eighth straw poll with 12 votes of encouragement. However, her candidacy faces potential diplomatic hurdles due to reported opposition from the United States, always fatal, and Russia. Rafael Mariano Grossi from Argentina, the Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency placed second in the eighth straw poll with nine votes in his favor. His high-profile nuclear diplomacy regarding Iran and Ukraine gives him deep crisis experience while also leaving him exposed to objections from rival geopolitical powers. According to the Council on Foreign Relations and Al Jazeera, the eight active candidates in the race also include Lana Zaki Nusseibeh from the United Arab Emirates (favored by the United States and Russia but apparently vetoed by the United Kingdom and France), María Fernanda Espinosa Garcés and Ivonne A-Baki from Ecuador, Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett from Guyana, Feridun Hadi Sinirlioğlu from Turkey and Olara Otunnu from Uganda.
With all eight official candidates receiving at least two “discourage” votes from the five permanent Security Council members during the November 20, 2026 straw poll, United Nations observers and civil society groups have floated several unannounced “dark horse” contenders who could be drafted as compromise options if the deadlock persists. According to the campaign tracker 1 for 8 Billion (a global civil society coalition campaigning for a transparent, accountable, and inclusive process to select the United Nations secretary general) and analysis from the Stimson Center (a nonprofit, nonpartisan policy research institute [think tank] based in Washington, D.C., focused on global peace, international security, and multilateral governance), the primary names circulating outside the current official ballot fall into two main categories.
Because informal United Nations regional rotation favors Latin America and the Caribbean for the 2027–2031 term, a principle publicly backed by the U.S. envoy to the United Nations and the Peoples’ Republic of China, diplomats looking for a fresh regional face have speculated about:
- Mia Mottley, the Barbadian Prime Minister who is widely recognized on the global stage for her climate finance advocacy (the Bridgetown Initiative) and could satisfy both regional rotation norms and calls for the first female Secretary-General.
- Alicia Bárcena, Mexico’s current Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources, former Foreign Secretary, and longtime Executive Secretary of the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC). Her extensive United Nations background and diplomatic standing make her a frequently mentioned regional fallback.
- David Choquehuanca, a former Bolivian Vice President and Foreign Minister has also been named in diplomatic speculation as a potential GRULAC alternative.
If the Security Council abandons regional rotation to break the stalemate (that’s how António Guterres was chosen over Eastern European candidates in 2016—observers point to several prominent international leaders:
- Kristalina Georgieva, the Bulgarian Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund and former World Bank chief executive officer who has deep multilateral management experience and was previously a late-entry candidate in 2016.
- Achim Steiner, the longtime Administrator of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is a seasoned United Nations insider who holds dual German and Brazilian citizenship.
- Jacinda Ardern, the former Prime Minister of New Zealand who is a recurring candidate in international speculation due to her high global profile and reputation for consensus-building.
- Nickolay Mladenov, a Bulgarian former United Nations Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process.
- Vuk Jeremić, the Serbian former United Nations General Assembly President and runner-up in 2016.
There is no formal nomination deadline for the United Nations Secretary-General race. If none of the existing eight candidates can clear the permanent-member veto hurdle prior to the departure of the sitting secretary general, a United Nations member state can submit a formal nomination letter to the Presidents of the General Assembly and Security Council at any time. In 2016, Kristalina Georgieva entered the race in late September, just weeks before the final October vote, demonstrating how quickly a compromise candidate can be introduced once front-runners stall.
Under Article 97 of the United Nations Charter, the Security Council uses closed-door straw polls until a candidate reaches at least nine votes without a veto from the five permanent members. The Council then puts forward a recommendation to the United Nations General Assembly for final appointment before the new term begins (this time on January 1, 2027). Interestingly, the Islamic Republic of Iran uses a similar vetting process when permitting the consideration of candidates for important posts. There, the vetting process for major political offices, including the Presidency, Parliament (Majlis), and the Assembly of Experts is primarily controlled by the Guardian Council with all prospective candidates required to pass the pre-election screening before their names can appear on a ballot. As detailed by Human Rights Watch, the 12-member Guardian Council is comprised of religious jurists and legal experts. The purposes, in each case (in both the United Nations and the Islamic Republic of Iran) is to assure that all candidates will continue to further the goals and aspirations of the principal members of the vetting mechanism. In the case of the United Nations, that would be the five permanent members of the Security Council each of which has veto power over all substantive issues (including selection of a secretary general) and effectively constitute a collective, if disputatious, self-serving oligarchy.
In reflecting on the United Nations’ next secretary general it seems appropriate to evaluate the performance of the current secretary general, Portugal’s António Guterres, although given the non-democratic nature of the selection process, the utility of such observation is probably illusory. However, perhaps some, at least, of the readers will find it of interest. A contextualizing starting point for analysis of Dr.[2] Guterres’ term should be the reflection by Albert Einstein in 1953 concerning the kind of people most responsible for the horrible experiences that have faced our world and which secretaries general of the United Nations should purportedly help avoid. Writing on March 30, 1953 in a tribute to Pablo Casals for his principled stand against Francisco Franco’s regime in Spain, Einstein wrote that “the world is in greater peril from those who tolerate … evil than from those who actually commit it”. That to me would be a fitting epithet to the role played during the past decade by António Guterres. A nice, well-meaning man who permitted the world to devolve into one the Nazis might well have been proud to claim as their own while wringing his hands and lamenting his inability to make a difference.
If the powers of his post as secretary general of the United Nations were truly so weak, an ethical man, a moral man, a decent man would have resigned in protest. That, I believe, is what Dag Hammarskjöld, Kofi Annan and U Thant, some of his predecessors in that role, might have done. He was certainly no Count Folke Bernadotte, a prominent Swedish nobleman and diplomat who worked closely with the United Nations in its early years, albeit not as secretary general but rather, as the first United Nations mediator in Palestine, appointed by the United Nations Security Council during the 1948 Arab–Israeli War. He was assassinated by Zionists in Jerusalem in September 1948 while carrying out that mission. But then again, the United Nations has never attained the purpose for which it was purportedly founded although it may well be the organization its principal proponents had hoped for when they replaced the old League of Nations. The League was “replaced” rather than reformed and improved because its members were unwilling to surrender absolute power to a limited group, i.e., what exists today, a body comprised of several hundred purportedly equal sovereign states ruled by a five state oligarchy as if they possessed Tolkien’s mythical “one ring to rule them all and in the darkness bind them”. Anyway, … thanks most of all to the United States, the selection process for United Nations secretaries general has “devolved” so that the António Guterres mold has become the norm: the most capable person is shunned at all costs in favor of the person who least offends (or frightens) the permanent members of the Security Council.
So, who is António Guterres? Well, he was born on April 30, 1949, in Lisbon during the authoritarian Estado Novo regime established by António de Oliveira Salazar (a former economics professor who ruled from 1932 to 1968), and later led by Marcelo Caetano until its collapse in 1974. He studied physics and electrical engineering at the Instituto Superior Técnico at the University of Lisbon, graduating with a bachelors’ degree in 1971. He worked briefly as an assistant professor teaching systems theory and telecommunications, while volunteering in Lisbon’s poorer neighborhoods through Catholic youth groups. Following Portugal’s 1974 Carnation Revolution, Guterres joined the Portuguese Socialist Party and was elected to the national parliament in 1976. He spent 17 years in parliament chairing key economic and administrative committees before becoming Secretary-General of the Socialist Party in 1992 and thereafter, in 1995, becoming prime minister in which role he oversaw Portugal’s adoption of the euro, the handover of Macau to China, and diplomatic efforts to resolve the independence crisis in East Timor. He also held the rotating presidency of the European Council in early 2000 and served as President of the Socialist International from 1999 to 2005. He resigned as Prime Minister in 2002 following local election losses and in 2005 he was appointed by the United Nations General Assembly as the High Commissioner for Refugees, a post he held for a decade. In that role, he restructured the agency and managed responses to massive global displacement caused by conflicts in Syria, Iraq, South Sudan, and Yemen and then, in 2017, on January 1, he assumed the role of secretary general of the United Nations succeeding Ban Ki-moon. Subsequently, having proven his utility to the permanent members of the Security Council by tearfully lamenting the declining respect for human rights and state sovereignty (but doing nothing to stem the tide), he was re-elected to a second five-year term that began in January 2022. Reflecting on his tenure, human rights advocates, diplomats, and international observers have criticized his consistent reluctance to confront powerful nations over human rights abuses and environmental depredation, his tolerance for genocide and ethnic cleansing, his perceived weakness in managing global conflicts and his internal administrative inconsistencies. On the other hand, the foregoing was just fine with the powers that be.
So, António is a decent human being, a good person, someone with an admirable curriculum vitae but, unfortunately, in his role as secretary general of the United Nations for the past decade, he’s been a person most of the world’s human rights activist will not be sorry to see go. Still, he’ll leave with the gratitude, albeit subtle (and superficially subdued) of the United States, the United Kingdom and France, as well as of the State of Israel, a de facto permanent member of the Security Council, and of the Russian Federation and People’s Republic of China. Of the Palestinians and the Syrians and the Libyans and the Lebanese and the Sudanese and the Iranians and the other oppressed people of the world, not so much. The future for them is not very promising, nor is it for the United Nations, or the world in general.
In his defense, António Guterres only tolerated evil. He didn’t actually commit it. But in a jury comprised of Albert Einsteins that would be a pretty serious indictment.
_____
© Guillermo Calvo Mahé; Manizales, 2026; all rights reserved. Please feel free to share with appropriate attribution.
Guillermo (“Bill”) Calvo Mahé (a sometime poet and aspiring empirical philosopher) is a writer, geopolitical commentator and academic currently residing in the Republic of Colombia (although he has primarily lived in the United States of America of which he is also a citizen). Until 2017 he chaired the political science, government and international relations programs at the Universidad Autónoma de Manizales. Previously, he chaired the social studies and foreign language departments at the Eastern Military Academy in Huntington, New York. He is currently the publisher of the Inannite Review available at Substack.com; an intermittent commentator on radio and television in both Colombia and abroad; and, an occasional contributor to diverse periodicals and publications. He has academic degrees in political science (BA, The Citadel, the Military College of South Carolina), law (JD, St. John’s University, School of Law), international legal studies (LL.M, the Graduate Division of the New York University School of Law) and translation and linguistic studies (GCTS, the University of Florida’s Center for Latin American Studies). However, he is also fascinated by mythology, religion, physics, astronomy and mathematics, especially with matters related to quanta, cosmology and cosmogony. He can be contacted at guillermo.calvo.mahe@gmail.com and much of his writing is available through his blog at https://guillermocalvo.com/.
[1] See generally Wintour, Patrick (2026): “Race to be next UN secretary general exposes divisions among world powers; Patrick Wintour, Diplomatic Editor, The Guardian, London available at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/20/race-to-be-next-un-secretary-general-exposes-divisions-among-world-powers?CMP=GTUK_email.
[2] While António Guterres never earned an academic doctoral degree, several institutions have granted him Doctor Honoris Causa degrees.








